Vallecito Lake/Bayfield CO Homes For Sale

Vallecito Lake/Bayfield CO Homes For Sale

View all the homes for sale in Vallecito Lake/Bayfield CO at a median price for all buyers. See pricing and listing details of Vallecito Lake/Bayfield real estate for sale.

Vallecito Lake/Bayfield CO Homes For Sale

$1,950,000
5 Beds 6 Baths 837513 MLS
Vallecito's luxury Trout House- an extra ordinary one-of-a-kind waterfront retreat where spectacular Vallecito Creek meets the pristine waters of Vallecito Lake (reservoir). Perfectly positioned on a .27acre lot, this remarkable 4,544 square foot mountain lodge offers 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms with breathtaking views of the lake, meandering creek and surrounding San Juan Mountains. Designed to embrace its unparalleled setting, this home blends authentic Colorado rustic elegance with exceptional craftsmanship and modern comfort. Two full living levels, each feature beautifully appointed kitchens and dining areas, making the home ideal for entertaining, hosting and accommodating guests. A stunning handcrafted log spiral staircase serves as the architectural centerpiece, while an elevator provides effortless access between each level. Gather around the warmth of multiple fireplaces and woodstoves or enjoy the comfort of central heating throughout the home. The luxurious primary suite offers a spa -inspired retreat with a beautifully tiled ensuite bath designed for relaxation after a day of mountain adventures. Step outside and experience what makes this property truly unforgettable - cast a fishing line directly from your deck into legendary Vallecito Creek, relax to the soothing sounds of flowing water, or simply take in the incredible scenery from every direction. Located in the charming mountain resort community of Vallecito, this exceptional property is surrounded by the San Juan National Fores and offers easy access to the renowned Weminuche Wilderness, Colorado's largest designated wilderness area. Enjoy year-round recreation including fishing, boating, paddleboarding, kayaking, hiking, horseback riding, snowmobiling and endless opportunities to explore the beauty of Southwest Colorado. Whether you're searching for a luxurious full-time residence, an unforgettable retreat, or an exceptional investment opportunity, The Trout House is a rare legacy property where mountain luxury meets an unrivaled waterfront lifestyle.

19786 County Road 501, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$1,125,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 837414 MLS
Perched at the top of Lake View Drive, this stunning custom home offers panoramic views of Vallecito Reservoir and the San Juan National Forest, creating the ultimate mountain retreat. Built in 2022, this thoughtfully designed 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sits on a 1-acre lot, and the adjoining 1.1-acre parcel is included in the sale, providing additional privacy and future development potential. The main living level is designed to showcase the incredible scenery with dramatic 10-foot floor-to-ceiling windows that flood the home with natural light. The open-concept living area features luxury vinyl plank flooring, a beautiful wood-burning fireplace, and seamless access to multiple outdoor living spaces. The modern kitchen offers granite and quartz countertops, premium Bosch stainless steel appliances, beverage refrigerator drawers, and an impressive butler's pantry complete with its own sink, garbage disposal, abundant cabinetry, and generous prep space. Outdoor living is just as impressive with three Trex decks positioned on three sides of the home, each offering a unique perspective of the surrounding mountains and lake. The expansive west-facing deck has been professionally engineered to support a hot tub and is already plumbed for one, while the south-facing deck captures spectacular lake and mountain views. A substantial pergola with built-in lighting and a heater creates the perfect year-round outdoor entertaining space. A loft overlooking the living area provides the ideal space for a home office, reading nook, or additional flex space. Off the kitchen and living room down the hall, the guest bedroom enjoys its own private deck and located next to a full guest bathroom with heated floors. The spacious primary suite is a true sanctuary, offering incredible private views of the San Juan National Forest, abundant natural light, a closet with the washer and dryer inside, a private entrance to the west-facing deck, and a beautifully appointed ensuite 3/4 bathroom featuring heated floors. The lower level features a heated two-car garage, a dedicated office or flex room just off the garage (not counted in square footage), and an oversized mechanical room/workshop complete with a large safe that conveys with the property. The garage also includes 220-volt power for added versatility. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, additional features include closed-cell foam insulation, heated gutters to help prevent snow slide-off, a private well, instant hot water with a water recirculation system, Wi-Fi-enabled smart home controls, Hunter Douglas motorized shades, and smart-enabled appliances that can be controlled from your phone. Extensive fire mitigation has already been completed around the home, providing added peace of mind. Located at the end of the subdivision with minimal traffic, this peaceful property offers exceptional privacy while remaining an excellent full-time residence, mountain getaway, or vacation rental opportunity. The property is part of the Lake Vista Valley Estates Subdivision, where property owners contribute just $500 annually toward private road maintenance and snow removal; there are covenants, but no HOA. This is a rare opportunity to own a modern mountain home in Vallecito with unmatched views, luxury finishes, exceptional outdoor living, and the added value of an included adjacent parcel.

1165 Lake View Dr, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$699,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 837161 MLS
Tucked in the heart of Vallecito, this charming 1472SF furnished cabin sits on TWO SEPERATELY DEEDED LOTS totaling 2 acres. The gated entrance ensures privacy and security while maintaining the peaceful mountain setting. Inside, the main level welcomes you with an open living and dining area anchored by a wood-burning fireplace—perfect for gathering on cool mountain evenings. The updated kitchen blends modern touches with rustic charm, and has been tastefully updated with newer cabinets and appliances. The sunny solarium adds a cozy spot to relax and flows out to a spacious covered deck where you can take in the quiet beauty of the woods. Also on the main level is a comfortable bedroom with a cedar closet, full bathroom, and a laundry room. Upstairs, you’ll find a guest bedroom, bonus room (currently used as a 3rd bedroom), full bath, and a loft area for extra sleeping or lounging space. Step out onto the upper deck and enjoy views of the tall spruce and pine trees that surround the home. The oversized one-car garage provides plenty of room for gear, while the covered area beside it makes firewood storage simple and convenient. The extra lot provides the flexibility to add additional structures, making it ideal for creating a family compound with space for a guest home or separate dwelling. With Vallecito Lake just down the road, days can be filled with fishing, kayaking, and boating before returning to your own private retreat in the pines.

11 & 17 Ponderosa Homes Dr, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$799,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 836931 MLS
Welcome to 531 Vallecito Creek Road, a spacious mountain retreat just minutes from Vallecito Reservoir. With over 2,400 square feet on a .65-acre lot, this home is designed for gathering, entertaining, and enjoying the Colorado lifestyle. Inside, you’ll find the perfect balance of openness and defined spaces. The large kitchen offers generous counter space, plenty of room to cook and connect, and a walk-in pantry. Multiple doors lead to outdoor living spaces, including a covered back deck, a covered front porch, and a beautifully manicured front yard—ideal for summer evenings and weekend barbecues. The main level features two ensuite bedrooms, one with an adjoining workout or overflow room, along with a powder room, laundry, and access to the attached two-car garage. Upstairs are two additional large bedrooms, a shared full bath, and a versatile loft space. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or anyone needing extra room will appreciate the oversized garage with a dedicated workshop, plus an additional detached shed/workshop for even more storage and flexibility. Ample parking adds to the convenience. Please be sure to take the 3D tour! With mature landscaping, partial fencing, and easy access to all the recreation Vallecito has to offer, this property combines comfort and functionality in a beautiful setting. Whether you’re gathering with friends, relaxing on the porch, or exploring the nearby trails, this home is the perfect base for all of your Colorado adventures.

531 Vallecito Creek Rd, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$539,999
3 Beds 2 Baths 836625 MLS
Mountain Views, River Sounds, and Total Serenity — Just north of Vallecito Lake, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-level home offers 2,216 sq. ft. of light-filled living space, two expansive decks, and the soothing sound of the river just one lot away. Designed for Zone 3 and loaded with upgrades, it’s the perfect year-round residence or mountain retreat. Just north of Vallecito Lake, this 2216 sq. ft. single-level home offers mountain views, peace, and quiet with the river only one lot away. The home is bright, spacious, and well-maintained, featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and numerous upgrades: a new heavy-duty ProPanel roof (2024), fresh interior and exterior paint (2024), new 50-gallon water heater, new dishwasher, and professionally cleaned carpet. Enjoy low-maintenance living with immaculate landscaping, well-planned drainage on both sides, and a beautiful waterfall feature. Two large decks provide perfect outdoor space for entertaining or relaxing to the sound of the river. Sturdy 2x6 framing, excellent water with a filtration system, and plenty of storage add to the home’s value. Additional structures include a 20'x12' insulated building with power and TV hookups—ideal for an office, studio, or guest space—and a 20'x8' storage shed. A propane whole house generator is also included. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a mountain getaway, or an investment property, the ability to operate a short-term rental offers added flexibility and income potential. *some photos of this listing may include virtually staged amenities, furniture or fixtures.

64 Pinion Ln, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$495,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 836429 MLS
Water's Edge Cabin | Rare Lakefront Opportunity on Lake Vallecito Opportunities like this are incredibly rare. On Lake Vallecito, only a handful of properties sit directly on the water, and Water's Edge Cabin is one of those exceptional lakefront retreats that seldom comes to market. These are the kinds of properties where generations gather, traditions are created, and memories last a lifetime. After decades of cherished family ownership, it is now time for a new family to make this special place their own. Nestled along the shoreline of beautiful Lake Vallecito, this mountain cabin offers unobstructed lake views and one of Southwest Colorado's most scenic waterfront settings. Ideally located between Durango and Bayfield and just a short walk to the marina, the property combines peaceful seclusion with easy access to recreation and amenities. Wake up each morning to panoramic views of the lake, enjoy coffee on the deck as the sun rises over the water, and spend your days immersed in the mountain lifestyle. Perched just above the shoreline, the cabin provides direct access for fishing, canoeing, kayaking, and endless lakeside enjoyment. Multiple outdoor decks create the perfect setting for grilling, relaxing, entertaining, or simply taking in the fresh mountain air. Inside, nearly every room showcases stunning lake views, creating a warm and tranquil atmosphere throughout. The cabin features a full kitchen, three sleeping areas, two bathrooms, and an inviting open-concept living and dining space complete with a Smart TV and electric fireplace—ideal for gathering after a day of adventure. Recent 2026 updates include new carpet and flooring on the main level, painted kitchen cabinets, a new refrigerator, new bar countertop and stools, updated furnishings, refreshed décor, the addition of an electric fireplace, and a refinished deck, enhancing both comfort and style while maintaining the cabin's timeless character. Sleeping Arrangements Main Bedroom (Main Level): Double Bed Upper Loft Area: Queen Bed and Twin Bed Upper Loft Area: Twin Bed Located in the heart of the Lake Vallecito recreation area, outdoor adventure awaits just beyond your doorstep. Enjoy boating, fishing, hiking, mountain biking, ATV trails, hunting, snowshoeing, snowmobiling, and access to the stunning San Juan Wilderness. Nearby you'll find restaurants, general stores, and marina services. The property is approximately 25 miles from historic downtown Durango and about 50 miles from Purgatory Ski Resort. Whether you're searching for a family getaway, a legacy property, or the ultimate Colorado lakefront retreat, Water's Edge Cabin offers a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own one of Lake Vallecito's most coveted waterfront locations.

14564 County Road 501, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$1,775,000
835867 MLS
"Custer's Mountain Meadow Ranch"  offers just the perfect escape to the San Juan Mountain's with it's cool summer time temperatures and endless outdoor recreation. Located in Vallecito, CO, just 12 miles from Bayfield, CO and 18 miles to Durango, CO.  Durango now has a state of the art hospital, the airport is now being expanded and has direct flights from many cities.  Custer's meadow sit's in the heart of Vallecito with the prefect location yet you feel that your deep in the San Juan Mountains and it's surrounding 1.8M acres of National Forest, and then add 500K acres of the Weminche Wilderness area which is considered some of the most beautiful, scenic areas  in all of Colorado, If your an outdoor enthusiast, an equestrian, hunter (CO offers OTC Elk tags for 2nd and 3rd rifle, BGU 75) , fisherman, mountain biker or trying to escape the heat this is your paradise!  Custer's Meadow is 40 +/- acres with it's own private 7 +/- acre lake with Lost Creek running thought the lower part of the meadow which flows directly into Vallecito Lake which is a 5 min walk directly from the ranch. The meadow is lush, green and has the perfect location and ready  to build your dream home or homes with views of your own lake and Vallecito Lake, and the surrounding San Juan Mountains.  Vallecito Lake is almost 2800 +/- acres and is crystal clear and offers just incredible  fishing. The lake has produced 30lb pike, and is filled with large Rainbows, Browns, and German trout. Vallecito Lake has a very nice marina and offers boat rentals for all your summer time lake activities.  Vallecito Lake is also a year round destination with Purgatory Ski Resort in Durango, and some of the best and deepest snow in Colorado is at Wolf Creek Ski Resort in Pagosa Springs, CO. Vallecito itself is known for it endless XC skiing trials and snowmobiling.  Custer's Meadow has super easy year round access and is extremely unique, and is one of the largest meadows in town and has to be seen and felt. Some additional  facts about Custer's Meadow, it's zoned for two units per acre, and sits at a mild 7800 elevation, power is at the property,  there is one water tap from a 3rd party well, 3-4 CFS SR water rights which is HUGE (water is becoming a major issue and this property has a ton of water)  the water rights date back to 1882, it's fenced and crossed fenced and currently generates $8500 +/- per year in pastor leases.

156 Golden Forest Rd, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$799,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 834979 MLS
Custom built in mountain style and on live water (!) .... this beautiful log sided home provides everything you need for year-round or seasonal Colorado living. Situated in one of the best Vallecito neighborhoods, 'The Mushrooms", it is also at the end of a quiet, private, cul-de-sac where Boletus Creek runs through the pond on the back of the property enroute to Vallecito Lake. ~ ~ ~ This efficient home offers all the features you would want for enjoying your own cozy place in the mountains. The living room, with a cathedral ceiling and tall windows highlighting the recently refinished Hickory hardwood floor, focuses around the large river-rock stone fireplace with an economical wood-burning insert. This area flows into the open kitchen showcasing new quartz countertops and island seating. There is also an adjacent dining area plus a slider to the enclosed sunporch, with a separate gas heater for alfresco-style dining, to enjoy the view of the spring fed natural pond and access out to the flagstone patio and Boletus Creek. ~ ~ ~ The spacious primary suite is also on the main level with full height ceilings, its own gas fireplace and a large, ensuite full bath with jetted tub and walk-in closet. Another bedroom is on the upper level, via a staircase, where the great room ceiling vaults up into a family room/office space which overlooks the living room and pond. The separate second bedroom, also with pond side views, and a full bath are also on this level. The new carpeting in these areas keeps it cozy too. ~ ~ ~ The third bedroom is accessed through the utility room and above the oversized, insulated, two car attached garage/shop. This is actually a private one-bedroom guest quarters, featuring a living room complete with a propane heating stove (in additional to electric baseboard heat), a separate bedroom, 3/4 bath, kitchenette, and lots of character with its locally harvested spruce T&G ceiling, and a small balcony overlooking the pond which also encompasses views of Vallecito Lake a mile or two south. The perfect spot for family or guests, they might never leave! ~ ~ ~ The home is on central water and sewer and has been meticulously maintained with a new high efficiency propane furnace in 2023 for the forced air heat and other updates including the conversion to a Navien on-demand water heater. The grounds around the home are attractively but naturally landscaped amongst the towering blue spruce trees, and there is a flagstone back patio and garden beds surrounding the pond. From the covered entry deck on the front of the home you can relax and enjoy distant mountain views to the north. ~~~ With Vallecito Lake only minutes away in either direction and being surrounded by the San Juan National Forest and the Weminuche Wilderness area there are more trail and year-round recreation options than can be listed. Come visit this special retreat!

367 Boletus Creek Dr, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$424,875
3 Beds 3 Baths 834524 MLS
Tucked into a charming subdivision with year-round access and located just minutes from Vallecito Marina, this inviting single-level 3 bedroom w/office, 3 bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, functionality, and mountain lifestyle living. Situated on 0.88 acres, the property provides an exceptional amount of usable space, privacy, and long-term potential. Surrounded by peaceful mountain scenery and backing to Bureau of Reclamation land with no backyard neighbors, the setting feels quiet and private while still remaining easily accessible from paved roads. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, seasonal retreat, or a property with room to spread out and enjoy the outdoors, this one checks a lot of your boxes. Inside, the home features over 1,600 square feet of comfortable living space with abundant natural light, and a practical split-bedroom design that works well for a variety of living situations. The layout offers two potential primary suite options—one featuring spacious closet space and a beautifully finished bathroom, and another with direct patio access and its own private entrance, creating ideal flexibility for guests, multi-generational living, or a private office setup. The third bedroom can easily function as a guest room, hobby room, workout space, or home office depending on your needs. Outdoor living is a standout feature here. The expansive patio and surrounding yard create a wonderful setting for entertaining, relaxing, gardening, or simply enjoying the peaceful Colorado surroundings. The flat grassed area offers plenty of room for pets, recreation, or future possibilities. One of the most impressive features of the property is the massive finished detached oversized garage/shop that has all the versatility you’d want. Complete with remote-controlled doors and substantial overhead attic storage accessed by a drop-down ladder, the space is ideal for vehicles, boats, side-by-sides, tools, workshop use, or all the recreational gear and toys that comes with Southwest Colorado living. The amount of storage, utility and privacy here is difficult to find in this price range. Located near one of Colorado’s most scenic recreational areas, you’ll enjoy quick access to Vallecito Lake, boating, fishing, hiking, mountain biking, and endless outdoor adventure while still having the convenience of year-round accessibility. With its combination of usable acreage, multiple lots, mountain views, flexible floorplan, incredible garage/shop space, and close proximity to Vallecito Lake, 57 Pine Drive offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the Colorado lifestyle in a setting that feels both peaceful and practical.

57 Pine Dr, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$750,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 834016 MLS
Furnished, STR-friendly waterfront home represents a rare opportunity to own a slice of alpine paradise in Vallecito. Stylish home on the quiet back side of Vallecito Lake with rare water-front Vallecito Creek frontage and no HOA. This well-lit three-bed, two-bath retreat offers both comfort and versatility, with a layout that works beautifully as a primary residence, vacation home, or income-producing property. The lock-off loft, complete with a pool table, and private entrance, has a history as a short-term rentals, and the tiny home near the creek is ideal for guests or additional income. An insulated shed provides a perfect hobby space, gym or overflow storage, and three additional outbuildings offer room for tools, gear, and outdoor vehicles such as ATVs. Large windows on the lower level fill the home with natural light, while the expansive deck features a concealed hot tub for relaxing evenings under the pines. Follow the steps down to a riverfront fire pit for peaceful mornings or summer nights by the water. Importantly, the property is NOT located in a designated FEMA flood zone, offering peace of mind rarely found with waterfront homes. The property is just 0.5 miles from the 19.5-mile Vallecito Trail, which leads directly into the Weminuche Wilderness and offers exceptional access to hiking, fishing, and outdoor recreation. This unique property blends mountain charm with practical flexibility. Photos taken in 2023 and June 2026.

148 Black Bear Ln, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$529,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 832470 MLS
Rare opportunity to own a beautifully refreshed, fully furnished Vallecito Lake retreat set along the highly desirable banks of Vallecito Creek. This property offers the peaceful mountain setting buyers dream about—whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or an investment property with a proven rental history. Inside, the home welcomes you with a bright and inviting atmosphere that blends modern touches with the relaxed charm of mountain living. The living, dining, and kitchen areas flow effortlessly together, creating an open and comfortable space for everyday living or gathering with family and friends. Large windows allow natural light to pour in while bringing the surrounding landscape into view. The home’s split floor plan offers a functional layout with added privacy, placing the primary suite on one side of the home while two additional bedrooms are positioned on the opposite side, creating a comfortable separation of space. An attached two-car garage and dedicated laundry/mudroom add everyday convenience and practical storage for gear after a day spent enjoying the surrounding area. Step outside and you’ll immediately appreciate the peaceful surroundings that make this location so special. Mature trees, a sense of privacy, and the soothing sound of flowing water nearby create a relaxing environment to unwind and enjoy Colorado’s changing seasons. The outdoor space offers room to gather, relax, and take in the natural beauty that makes Vallecito such a beloved destination. The property also features two RV hookups located in the backyard, providing added flexibility for guests or additional recreational use. Located just minutes from Vallecito Lake, making it easy to enjoy boating, fishing, and the many recreational opportunities the area has to offer. Historic Durango is just a comfortable drive away, offering restaurants, shopping, and year-round community events whenever you feel like heading into town. With its inviting layout, scenic setting, strong rental potential, and sought-after Vallecito location, this property presents a rare opportunity to own a special piece of Colorado mountain living. The Property being marketed and offered for sale consists of two (2) separate legal lots, 537720414004 (112 Spruce Ln) & 537720414003 (136 Spruce Ln). Both lots are included in this transaction and are being offered and sold together as a single package.

112 & 136 Spruce Ln, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

$295,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 831239 MLS
Location, location, location! Overlooking Lake Vallecito, this mountain cabin offers an inviting opportunity to enjoy one of Southwest Colorado’s most scenic lake settings. Built in 1951, the home features 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and 672 square feet, situated on .31 acres with beautiful lake views and convenient year-round access. The property is being sold as-is, yet remains functional and livable, offering the option for a buyer to move in and enjoy it now while completing cleaning, updates, or improvements over time. This makes it well suited for those seeking a manageable mountain retreat with potential, rather than a full renovation project. A large natural rock formation helps shield the property from highway noise and adds unique character, with the potential to become a beautiful rock garden or landscaped feature. The setting feels private while still offering easy access to nearby amenities. Vallecito Lake is a renowned recreation area offering boating, fishing, hiking, camping, and winter activities, all set against the dramatic backdrop of the San Juan Mountains. The home is located near outdoor access areas and hiking trails, ideal for daily walks and adventure, and benefits from easy winter access to the highway. Outside of real estate contracts the ATV and trailer are also for sale. According to the 2024 FEMA Floodplain map on the La Plata County GIS website this property is not in a floodplain.

17331 County Road 501, Vallecito Lake/Bayfield

Start Your Search

board logoThe data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2026. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to limited license rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited. FULL CREN Disclaimer Real Estate listings held by companies other than CREN contain that company's name. Fair Housing Disclaimer This data was last updated: